"How many other illusions do I experience, along with this one that fools me into thinking I'm capable of choosing my own direction." (59)
She gets lost in the idealistic life presented to her by so many others. Self identity is hard in high school, as a Cuban American she struggles with where she belongs. Margarita grapples with finding her place with older boyfriends, drugs and war protests.
"Do I need to alter my own definition of self?" (74)
Margarita hopes that she has found her place at UC Berkeley, instead she feels lost as a freshman. Slowly she finds things that she loves such as the beauty of the Hindi language, but she is also easily influenced as she tries to find her identity. Strikes and riots equal missed tests and flunked classes. Margarita finds herself lost, easily persuaded as she still holds onto her childhood dreams of Cuba.
"I've lost my identity
no longer a student
my face in the mirror
this dropout
a stranger." (83)
No school, no job, no home Margarita leaves readers wondering why she doesn't go home to start new again. Instead she joins a commune, learns a trade, she roams the woods and once again is manipulated as she holds on to her dream of returning to Cuba.
"This time, I won't give up.
I need to learn how to help feed the hungry
with roots, shoots, seeds, fruit
and perseverance." (147)
"Hope follows wherever we go." (157)
This is Margarita's story of leaving her childhood, having hopes and dreams and teaching us that sometimes we must be lost before we can find ourselves and start again.
Students
that enjoy this type of verse novel, although still nonfiction may also enjoy Inside Out and Back Again and Words with Wings. Nonfiction
written in this format is personal and it is because of the format that
students can be drawn into another culture or experience. They are relatable and make a good platform for beginning classroom
discussions and would serve as a lead in on each of their own particular topics
or together on a broader topic of self-identity. While these three books
range in age recommendations as low as third for Inside Out and Back again, Lexile level of 800, up to 7th grade to high
school for Soaring Earth, Lexile level 1190, I think all three would
be excellent collections to a school library.
Engle, M. (2019). Soaring earth. New York, NY: Atheneum.
Thanhha, L. (2013). Inside out and back again. New York, NY: Harper Collins
Grimes, N. (2013). Words with wings. New York, NY: Penguin.

Jennifer, you've got another great post here! I am very interested in reading this book after going through your review! I think you have a lot of awesome passages portrayed here and I completely agree, books on self identity are so important to young readers. I love that this book also brings in cultural awareness and diversity representation, as do your read alikes. Great post! I'm off to add this to my Goodreads 'to read' list.
ReplyDeleteI didn't realize when I first started this book that it is a companion to Enchanted Air. Now I need to go read that one and then reread Soaring Earth.
ReplyDelete